| |
| CNA
-
Communication Need Assessment Programme
|
| |
Role
of communication in HIV prevention
| |
"The
most effective prevention messages are
those which help provide skills to be
used interpersonally regarding refusal,
delay, and negotiation: ability to say
no when pressured to have sex, to put
off sex if unwanted, and to negotiate
to use condoms. Role plays, rehearsals,
et cetera, are most critical. Unfortunately,
politics, religion, and supposed values
often get in the way of delivering the
messages that would be most likely to
succeed: 'remain abstinent if you can,
but learn how to negotiate for condom
use if you're already active.'" Our
personal interest is to develop this activity
as a social movement, outside the money
system, outside of all institutional structures.
Others could try different models. Here
is a way we can work every day to build
a better life for ourselves, and a better
world for all people, through exactly
the same actions.
How does this relate to HIV prevention?
Some programs already recognize a critical
synergy of appeals -- teaching skills
not only for disease prevention, but also
for personal autonomy, and also (most
important to adolescents, and many others
as well) for social success. We suggest
adding another element: programs where
most of the learning takes place not in
a group meeting, or while reading a poster
or otherwise receiving a public-service
message, but through well-designed, low-stress
communication practices to do on one's
own within the social context of everyday
life. Then these practices can be delivered
to the community in many ways, especially
through leadership that already exists,
including celebrities, and also including
the natural leaders of local (or Internet)
social scenes. Also, new scenes could
be created to address pressing needs.
|
|
|
In
order to plan and implement the future IEC strategies
in a scientific manner, TNSACS has decided to assess
the needs and strategies for better communication. The
ensuing sections of the final report, submitted by M/s.
AC Nielsen, details the findings of the communication
needs assessment study, which was conducted in the State
of Tamil Nadu in three urban and three rural districts.
The study was conducted among the following population
sub-groups: -
| |
Commercial
Sex Workers
Men having sex with Men
Truck drivers and helpers
IV Drug users
Population
Sub-groups
Prisoners
Migrant Labourers
Street Children
Students
Clients to CSWs
Research Objectives
|
|
|
| |
To
assess the knowledge of STD/HIV/AIDS among
population and specific population subgroups.
To identify the actual target audience
for communicating the messages related
to STD/HIV/AIDS. To identify approaches
and means of communication most effective
for the target groups. Analyse the existing
materials used in the state for STD/HIV/AIDS
control and assess the acceptance. Assess
the groups who will be helpful in preventing
STD/HIV/AIDS among the high risk groups
and suggest the best way of reaching this
group and recommend suitable communication
strategy. Evaluating the adequacy of the
existing media and need for modification,
if any.
|
|
|
Indicators
| |
Awareness
of STD/HIV/AIDS
Awareness of cause of infection
Awareness of sources of infection
Knowledge on ways that the HIV/AIDS virus
spreads
Ways to prevent STD/HIV/AIDS
Differentiation between STD, HIV &
AIDS
Sources of knowledge
Appropriate perception of risk
Proportion of respondents with risk behaviour
who perceive appropriately that they are
at risk of contracting HIV/AIDS
Misconceptions with regard to spread of
virus
Exposure to risk
The nature of disease
Attitude towards influencing groups (such
as NGOs, Counselors, Doctors, Drama Artists,
Peers etc.)Likeability of various groups
Credibility of various groups
Media related issues
Media exposure
Intensity of exposure to each Media
|
|
|
Research
Methodology
Though
the awareness strategies / IEC activities of TNSACS
are addressed basically to general population, the messages
generally reach the following population sub-groups:-
| |
CSWs,
truck drivers and helpers, migrant labourers,
MSM, IV drug users, prisoners, students,
street children, clients to CSWs. The
study covered each of these population
sub-groups in detail. The above categories
were covered in both urban and rural centres.
|
|
|
The following districts were
covered in the study:-
| |
Urban
Coimbatore Madurai Trichy Salem
Rural
Namakkal Villupuram Vellore
Sample
Size
Population sub-groups covered
Commercial sex workers (CSWs)
Migrant Labourers
Truck Drivers
Students
Men having sex with men (MSM)
Prisoners
Street Children
Clients to CSWs
IV Drug Users
|
|
|
Sampling
Method
Commercial Sex
Workers
Truck Drivers and
Helpers
Migrant Labourers
Commercial Sex workers
All the areas in the sample towns
where CSWs operate were mapped using the Delphi Technique.
The information sources in this regard were:-
| |
Cycle
rickshaw pullers
Auto rickshaw drivers
Pimps
Hotel/Lodge owners
Policemen
After
all the sites where CSWs operate were
identified, the required number of sites
were randomly selected. Around 20 interviews
were conducted at each site.
|
|
|
Truck Drivers and Helpers
| |
The
site fixation was done by physically identifying
all the areas where the truck drivers/helpers
congregate in the survey towns. After
all the sites were identified, then the
required number of sites were randomly
selected. Here again, 20 interviews were
conducted in each selected site.
|
|
|
Migrant
Labourers
The
site fixation was done by first physically identifying
all the localities where construction activities (building,
roads,etc.) were taking place in the study centres.
The information sources used in this regard were:-
| |
After
all the construction sites in the survey
towns were identified, the required number
of sites were randomly selected. In each
site, 10 effective interviews were conducted.
Further, migrant labourers belonging to
both sexes were covered.
|
|
|
Students
| |
Both
male and female students were covered.
School students studying in class-XI &
XII, as well as college students pursuing
any discipline were covered. The institutes
within each survey town were selected
by ensuring geographical spread and adequate
representation of that town. 10 interviews
were done in each selected institute.
|
|
|
Men
having sex with men (MSM)
| |
Since
MSMs segment is difficult to identify
by normal means, the respondent contact
for this segment was done with the aid
of NGOs (such as Prakriti, ICWO etc.)
The required number of interviews was
done through purposive sampling thereafter.
|
|
|
IV
Drug Users
| |
The
sampling procedure followed for this segment
was similar to that of MSMs since this
segment is also difficult to identify
by normal means.
|
|
|
Prisoners
| |
The
inmates of the main central jails in three
key study centres were covered. The support
of Inspector General of Police (Prisons)
was taken for this purpose. The respondents
were randomly selected based on the number
assigned to them by the jail authorities.
The total sample was proportionately distributed
across the central jails in three study
centres.
|
|
|
Street Children
| |
NGOs
Municipal corporation / Government departments
The required number of sites was randomly
selected. The actual respondent identification
was done through snow balling method.
Around 10 interviews were conducted in
each selected site.
Clients to female CSWs
This
segment was primarily identified at the
pre-mapped sites where CSWs operate. Around
10 interviews were conducted in each site.
Findings
Among Sub - Groups
|
|
|
Findings Among Sex Workers
| |
1.
Awareness and knowledge about STD is quite
high
2.
Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is almost universal
The main media from
where HIV/ AIDS messages are recalled:
| |
(a) TV
(b) Radio
(c) Health workers/ NGOs |
3.
Majority feel that the Government needs
to initiate and continue steps towards
providing HIV/ AIDS related knowledge
to people
With respect to
expectation regarding the media that could
be used for educating CSWs, the following
media were mentioned prominently : -
| |
(a)
TV
(b) Radio
(c) Direct contact with Health workers/
NGOs |
4.
Interestingly, only a small proportion
of CSWs contacted, expected written material
like books/ pamphlets to be given to them.
5. Certain gaps noticed with respect to
knowledge about prevention of HIV/ AIDS
Therefore, the focus of education should
be on methods to prevent HIV/ AIDS
|
|
|
Findings Among MSM
| |
1
Awareness of and knowledge about STD is
quite high
2 Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is universal
3 Knowledge about prevention of HIV/ AIDS
by using condoms and by not indulging
in unprotected multi partner sex is quite
high. There is some scope to increase
the knowledge about HIV/ AIDS prevention
through condom usage.
The main media from
where HIV/ AIDS messages are recalled
:
| |
(a)
Health workers/ NGOs
(b) TV
(c) Radio |
4
Vast majority feel that the Government
needs to initiate more steps towards providing
HIV/ AIDS related knowledge to people
With
respect to expectation regarding the media
that could be used for educating CSWs,
the following media were mentioned prominently:
-
Few other media
also received significant mention in this
regard: -
| |
(a)
Stickers behind buses/ autos
(b) Direct contact with health workers/
NGOs
(c) Hoarding/ wall painting
(d) Written material like pamphlets/
hand-outs
(e) Play/ Drama |
5
Certain degree of lack of awareness was
noticed with respect to prevention of
HIV/ AIDS. Therefore, increasing STD awareness
and education on methods for preventing
HIV/AIDS should be the focus of communication.
|
|
|
Findings Among Truckers
| |
1
Awareness of STD is moderate
2 Among those who are aware, the knowledge
about STD is quite good
3 Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is almost universal
The main media from
where HIV/ AIDS messages are recalled:
| |
(a)
TV
(b) Boards/ signs behind buses/ autos
(c) Newspaper/ Magazine
(d) Roadside Hoardings |
4
An overwhelming majority of truckers feel
that the Government needs to initiate
more steps towards providing HIV/ AIDS
related knowledge to people.
With
respect to expectation regarding the media
that could be used for educating truckers,
the following media were mentioned prominently:
-
| |
(a)
TV
(b) Cinema hall
(c) Newspaper/ magazine
(e) Stickers/ signs behind buses/
autos
(f) Roadside Hoardings
(g) Play/ drama |
5.
On the whole, this segment also exhibits
a reasonably high level of basic awareness
and knowledge about both STDs and HIV/
AIDS.
Therefore, the need for communication
per se is somewhat lower in this segment.
|
|
|
Findings Among IV Drug Users
| |
1
Awareness of and knowledge about STD is
quite high
2 Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is almost universal
3 Knowledge about prevention of HIV/ AIDS
by using sterilized needles / syringes
is quite high. However, relatively lesser
proportion seemed to know about condom
usage as a possible method of prevention
of HIV/ AIDS through sexual mode.
The main media from
where HIV/ AIDS messages are recalled:
| |
(a) Cinema
hall
(b) Health worker/ NGO
(c) Radio |
4
Majority of IV drug users feel that the
Government needs to initiate more steps
towards providing HIV/ AIDS related knowledge
to people. However, the proportion of
IV drug users who seek knowledge about
HIV/ AIDS is much lesser than other high
risk segments.
With
respect to expectation regarding the media
that could be used for educating CSWs,
the following media were mentioned prominently:
-
| |
(a)
Magazines and newspapers
(b) Radio
(c) TV (Note: - TV was mentioned much
lower than other high risk segments)
|
5.
On the whole, the need for communication
per se is much lower in this segment as
compared to other segments. The possible
area where some education could be provided
is with respect to condom usage as a method
for preventing HIV/AIDS (which is probably
not a priority area of concern for this
segment).
|
|
|
Findings Among Prisoners
| |
1
Awareness of and knowledge about STDs
is quite high.
2 Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is almost universal.
The main media from where HIV/ AIDS messages
are recalled :
| |
(a) TV
(b) Newspaper/ Magazine
(c) Radio |
4
An overwhelming majority of prisoners
feel that the Government needs to initiate
more steps towards providing HIV/ AIDS
related knowledge to people.
With
respect to expectation regarding the media
that could be used for educating prisoners,
the following media were mentioned prominently:
-
| |
(a)
TV
(b) Newspaper/ magazine
(c) Direct contact with health workers/
NGOs
(d) Direct contact with Doctors
(e) Direct contact with staff in Government
hospitals |
6
Interestingly, only a small proportion
of prisoners expected written material
like books/ pamphlets to be given to them.
7 Certain gaps noticed with respect to
knowledge about prevention of HIV/ AIDS-
particularly with respect to condom usage
as a preventive method against HIV/ AIDS.
Therefore, the focus of education should
be on methods to prevent HIV/ AIDS
|
|
|
Findings Among Migrant Labourers
| |
1
Awareness of STDs is moderate.
2 Among those who are aware, the knowledge
about STDs is quite good.
3 Awareness of HIV/ AIDS is almost universal.
4 Certain degree of knowledge gaps noticed
with respect to prevention of HIV/ AIDS-
particularly with respect to condom usage.
5 None of the media received very high
mention when migrant labourers were probed
about the media from where they had received
HIV / AIDS related messages. Only TV was
mentioned prominently in this regard.
A significant proportion also mentioned
radio and cinema halls.
6 An overwhelming majority of migrant
labourers feel that the Government needs
to initiate more steps towards providing
HIV/ AIDS related knowledge to people.
With respect to
expectation regarding the media that could
be used for educating prisoners, the following
media were mentioned prominently: -
| |
(a) TV
(b) Radio
(c) Cinema halls
(d) Newspaper / magazine
(e) Roadside Hoardings / Wall posters
(f) Direct contact with staff in Government
hospitals
(g) Play / drama |
|
|
|
Findings Among Street Children
| |
1
Awareness of and knowledge about both
STDs and HIV/ AIDS is quite low in this
segment
2 Significantly, majority of the street
children are unable to make up their mind
with respect to Government initiating
more steps towards providing HIV/ AIDS
related education to street children like
them. This could possibly be caused due
to the inability to articulate their needs
that is normally observed in many of the
children below 15 years.
|
|
|
Findings Among Students
| |
1
Awareness of both STDs and HIV/ AIDS is
quite low in this segment
2 However, among those who are aware about
these diseases, the knowledge levels are
quite high
Therefore, the focus of education should
be to increase the awareness about STDs
and HIV/ AIDS
The main media from
where HIV/ AIDS messages recalled are
as follows: -
| |
(a) TV
(b) Newspaper/ Magazine
(c) Radio |
3
Significantly, majority of the students
are unable to make up their mind with
respect to Government initiating more
steps towards providing HIV/ AIDS related
education to students like them. This
inability to articulate their needs could
be the possible reason.
|
|
|
Media Preference
| |
When
the respondents were probed on from which
media they would like to get educative
information on HIV/AIDS, some interesting
responses were obtained apart from the
expected response related to mass media
such as TV, Radio, Cinema and print ads.
Significant proportion of respondents
mentioned direct contact with health workers
/ social workers, doctors and hospital
staff as possible routes for spreading
HIV / AIDS related messages.
|
|
|
Impact of Inter-personal Communication
| |
In
general, the awareness levels on STD/ HIV/
AIDS are considerably high among all the
population sub-groups surveyed. Obviously,
the high awareness levels can be attributed
to the interventions done through mass media
like TV, radio, cinema and newspaper/ magazine
in the past few years. It is a well-known
fact that mass media vehicles are very effective
in creating general awareness levels of
the disease (viz., spreading horizontal
knowledge). However, these mass media vehicles
have limited application in imparting in-depth
vertical knowledge.
Interestingly,
the data clearly shows that personal attention
actually increases the depth of knowledge
related to the spread and prevention of
HIV/ AIDS, which is very important.
|
|
|
Impact of Interaction
| |
The
data on knowledge indicators was analysed
separately for those who had an interaction
with social workers (such as Health Workers,
Counselors, NGOs etc.) and those who did
not have an interaction with social workers.
From this table, it is clearly evident that
the knowledge levels are significantly higher
among the respondents who received information
from the social worker / counselor on an
one to one basis. On the whole, it can be
concluded that increased focus on mass media
may not necessarily lead to a considerable
change in the knowledge and behaviour of
the population sub-groups. However, personal
one to one interaction with specific groups
like Social workers, Counselors, Doctors
and NGOs might be more effective in dealing
with the misconceptions of people and in
educating them, particularly with regard
to the spread and prevention of HIV/ AIDS. |
|
|
Summary
|
|
|
|

|